May 1st, 2010

View from study (sunny)

Cleaning the house, one cupboard at a time...

I'm feeling somewhat frustrated that I'm not doing proper posts here. At least not what I consider proper posts. I'm just about keeping up with the photo-a-day and posting them here too so you know that I aten't dead, but I'm not using this journal for reflecting on Stuff, which I always find useful.

Anyway, I just have to do the final tweaks to the late essay for the BA Education course and make a poster out of the key points and then all my deadlines will be in the future. What a novel thought! :)

Once the heavy, dragging feeling of having overdue stuff hanging over me has gone, I'm hoping it will allow me to get on with other things, like doing something with all the seeds and plants I bought and spring cleaning the house. I have made a small start on the latter by cleaning out a couple of cupboards. I did the crockery cupboard the other week and today I did the tea cupboard.

I possibly have too many kinds of tea! I think I need to rationalise a little. I'm still not even sure whether I like camomile and chai, but I need to use those up and if I haven't definitely acquired a taste for them by the time the packs are finished, then I must not buy more!

Anyway, yesterday I bought a new china tea caddy and a few plastic containers to keep everything under control and ensure that it stays fresher so the teas are all nicely organised. This has to be progress of a sort...

In other news, now that we've had some rain, even though the weather has gone colder again, everything is bursting into leaf and starting to grow so today the view from the study window looks more or less like the icon.
  • Current Mood
    busy busy

Are critiques helpful?

Just thought I'd copy here something I said in one of the advanced creative writing forums for the OU course I'm currently doing (as a student).

A fellow student posted saying:

Do critiques help?

I'm stuck with my thing. I don't even want to look at it! Critiques are at total opposites with my structure. Can't please everybody. But how do we know who is right? Oh the subjectivity! I suppose we have to rely on our instinct? But can we trust it?!

This was my reply:

There are times when critiques definitely help. The typo that has been staring you in the face, but you can't see it because your brain reads what you meant to say, not what's actually on the page. Continuity errors are another, especially after a piece has been revised a couple of times. It's easy to think that you said something when you haven't because you've forgotten that it was in a paragraph that you deleted. Pacing, explaining too much or too little. Critiquers can definitely help with these.

Other things, probably not. Which viewpoint or verb tense, things like that, are more a matter of taste and opinion, so I'd say go with your instinct.

I know that, especially when they're beginners, writers (and I include my younger self here!) often feel that if only someone could come along and say, "Just delete this, add that, change this, leave that as it is," and voila! they would have a wonderful story that will sell to the first place they send it and be hailed as wonderful by everyone who reads it. Or in other words, they want the magic secret to writing the perfect story.

Is this what people secretly want when they ask for a critique? Any of you have any thoughts on whether critiques are useful or not? What sort of things do you expect a critique to pick up?